Skip to main content

Table 3 Hip RCT outcomes and their mapping to the three core and one optional OMERACT areas/domains

From: Do outcomes reported in randomised controlled trials of joint replacement surgery fulfil the OMERACT 2.0 Filter? A review of the 2008 and 2013 literature

Authors

Pathophysiological

Life impact

Death

All 3 core areas reported

Resource use/economic impacta

Pain

Stiffness

ROM

AE

Blood loss

RSA

RMAL

Satisfaction

Hip QoL

General QoL

Function

Activity levels

Mortality

 

LoI

Surgery time

LoS

Reop/readmit

Revision rate

Garcia-Rey 2008 [20]

√

 

√

   

√

   

√

        

Glyn-Jones 2008a [21]

√

    

√

√

   

√

        

Glyn-Jones 2008b [22]

   

√

 

√

             

Hamadouche 2008 [23]

√

 

√

√

  

√

   

√

 

√

√

    

√

Lachiewicz 2008 [24]

√

 

√

√

  

√

   

√

       

√

Macaulay 2008 [25]

√

√

√

√

     

√

√

 

√

√

     

Meneghini 2008 [26]

   

√

      

√

        

Mouzopoulos 2008 [27]

√

 

√

       

√

 

√

√

     

Pagnano 2008 [28]

   

√

     

√

√

√

       

Pitto 2008 [29]

√

 

√

   

√

   

√

        

Barrett 2013 [30]

√

 

√

√

√

 

√

 

√

 

√

   

√

√

√

  

Bjorgul 2013 [31]

√

 

√

 

√

 

√

   

√

 

√

√

 

√

  

√

Cadossi 2013 [32]

√

 

√

√

√

 

√

   

√

 

√

√

 

√

√

 

√

Desmarchelier 2013 [33]

√

 

√

√

  

√

√

  

√

√

√

√

    

√

Greidanus 2013 [34]

√

√

 

√

  

√

√

 

√

√

        

Hedbeck 2013 [35]

      

√

  

√

√

 

√

√

   

√

 

Inngul 2013 [36]

√

 

√

√

  

√

  

√

√

 

√

√

     

Kim 2013 [37]

√

√

√

   

√

   

√

√

√

√

     

Landgraeber 2013 [38]

√

√

√

√

√

 

√

   

√

 

√

√

√

√

   

Munzinger 2013 [39]

     

√

             

Naudie 2013 [40]

√

√

√

  

√

   

√

√

 

√

√

     

Penny 2013 [41]

√

√

√

√

√

    

√

√

√

  

√

√

√

  

Smolders 2013 [42]

      

√

     

√

      

Stiehler 2013 [43]

√

√

√

   

√

  

√

√

        

Venditolli 2013 [44]

      

√

          

√

√

Vidovic 2013 [45]

√

 

√

√

  

√

   

√

    

√

√

  

Zagra 2013 [46]

√

 

√

       

√

        
  1. 11 RCTs had all three core areas reported
  2. AE adverse events, RSA radiosteriometric analysis, RMAL radiographs to measure alignment or loosening, Satis satisfaction, QoL quality of life, LoI length of incision, LoS length of stay
  3. aArea/domain recommended, but not a core area